Monday, May 2, 2011

Christianity: Arrogant and Exclusive?

TITLE: Christianity: Arrogant and Exclusive?
Written by: Conrade Yap
Date: 2 May 2011
Jesus answered, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” (John 14:6)

MAIN POINT: Tackling the issue of exclusivity claimed by the Christian faith. Truth by nature is exclusive.

Credit: David Gunter
Many years ago, as a young Christian, I will engage in a vigorous debate with my well-educated uncle. A firm atheist, he is much against anyone who ventures beyond a private-only faith, to start sharing about their beliefs to others. In his view, a religion is for personal consumption. Anything other than a personal religion is considered a ‘crusade,’ a fanatical movement that attempts to shove the faith down another person’s spiritual throat. For my uncle, there is no need to be so serious about any religion. After all, he says defiantly:

  • That all religions are the same.
  • That all religions teach people to do good deeds.
  • That Christianity is wrong to claim sole right to eternity in heaven.
  • That it is preposterous for Christians to insist that Jesus is the ONLY way to heaven?

We debate through the night. We argue the pros and cons of religion. Like a chess game, we start well with our pieces on the board, exchange pieces throughout the game, and conclude at a stalemate. My uncle was at that time, an atheist. I think he died a free thinker, still refusing to believe in anything religious.

A) The Struggle with Exclusivity Claims

My uncle is not alone in his views. History has not been on the side of Christianity. The Crusades, the religious wars, the abuses of the Church have only gone to push non-believers further away from the gospel. How can there be good news when the practitioners themselves are harbingers of one bad news after another? How can any religion be good when it raises its own name above all other religion? How can anyone really believe in a God who chooses only some to go to heaven and condemns the rest to hell? Is Christianity an exclusive religion? Is it really true that Jesus is the only way to God? Then what about those people who are not able to know Jesus for some reason?

A number of weeks ago, I share about my struggle with Jesus’ words regarding such exclusivity. It is not about me not believing in Jesus. It is about how I can reconcile a loving God, with the issue of eternal hell for those who do not get to hear about Jesus. Admittedly, this issue has become a hot potato after the launch of Megachurch pastor Rob Bell’s book: “Love Wins.” It has been reported that Zondervan, one of the largest Christian book publishers in the world has terminated their publishing relationship with Rob bell over theological disagreements with Bell’s latest book. Harper-Collins, a secular book publisher has since jumped at the chance to sign Bell up, offering to publish “Love Wins.” It has become a huge money spinner for this New York based company. After all, nothing sells better than controversy. For all the right (and wrong) reasons, Rob Bell has garnered even more media attention.

Key Point: The struggle with John 14:6 is very much a struggle to reconcile man’s desire to choose his own path, vs the way of Jesus.

B) Love Wins?

Pastor Rob Bell has an interesting way of interpreting John 14:6. While Bell does not deny that salvation is through Jesus, he makes a bold claim that the verse does not say ‘how, or when, or in what manner’ people can get to Jesus. He then makes this rather confusing claim:

This kind insists that the all-embracing, saving love of this particular Jesus the Christ will of course include all sorts of unexpected people from across the spectrum. . . What Jesus does is declare that he, and he alone, is saving everybody. And then he leaves the door way, way open. Creating all sorts of possibilities. He is as narrow as himself and as wide as the universe.” (Rob Bell, Love Wins, NY: HarperOne, 2011, 155)

Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever LivedHe then goes to explain how Jesus is both exclusive (that he is the Way), and also inclusive (that there are many ways to Him). Some well-known evangelicals like John Piper has spoken out strongly against Bell. Others like the very popular Tim Challies says that Bell is a universalist, meaning that he believes in a kind of religion that believes all ways lead to heaven.

Like any controversy, with each opponent, there are also supporters. Eugene Peterson calls “Love Wins” a type of book that has ‘thoroughly biblical imagination.’ Richard Mouw, the President of Fuller Seminary calls “Love Wins” as well ‘within the bounds of orthodox Christianity’ and that Bell is one pastor who is ‘passionate about Jesus.’

My take on Rob Bell’s book is that ‘love’ seems to be his overriding rule of interpretation. I like the way of love. I really hope Rob Bell is right. The trouble is, has Bell compromised truth in the process? As I read the book, I get the uncomfortable feeling of whether Bell has confused ‘Love Wins’ with ‘Truth Wins.’ The culture we are living in can readily accept nice and easy ‘love.’ They are not so friendly toward ‘tough love.’ They are even more hostile toward 'truth claims.' As Christians, we are called to follow and to obey Christ. Love is an important demonstration of God’s love. Love is indeed a mark of a disciple of Christ. With love comes responsibility. A responsibility to share the truth. A duty to share the truth in love. It is not saying about things people like or do not like to hear. It is speaking out in truth and love, the truth that people NEED to hear.

Key Point: Man cannot define love. Only God can.

C) Christianity is Exclusive? Others are too.

I believe every word of John 14:6. I do not believe that all roads lead to the heavenly Father. We either choose Jesus, or reject Him. There is no middle ground. Not choosing or rejecting Jesus outright is already a choice in itself. The one who rejects Jesus will have to bear the consequences.

Christianity is not the only religion that is ‘exclusive.’ In other words, all other religions are by themselves exclusive. Let’s not kid ourselves into thinking that Christianity is selfish and exclusive. I think Ravi Zacharias says it very well as follows. Responding to an accusation that Christians are arrogant to claim Jesus as the one and only way to God, Zacharias replies:

First, it is important to understand that Christianity is not the only religion that claims exclusivity. For instance, Muslims radically claim exclusivity. As for Buddhism, it was born when Gautama Buddha rejected two fundamental assertions of Hinduism – the ultimate authority of the Vedas, which are their scriptures, and the caste system. Hinduism itself is absolutely uncompromising on two or three issues: the law of karma, which is the law of moral cause and effect, so that every birth is a rebirth that makes recompense for the previous life; the authority of the Vedas; and reincarnation. . . . As for Sikhism, it came as a challenge to both Hinduism and Buddhism. Then there are the atheists – they reject the viewpoints of those who believe in God. And even Baha’sm, which claims to be a cosmic embrace of all religions, ends up excluding the exclusivists!” (Ravi Zacharias, quoted by Lee Strobel in The Case for Faith, p148)

Sometimes, when Christians are ‘attacked’ by other religions about their statement of faith, remember that such attackers are themselves holding on to an exclusive view of their own! For example, why are atheists so sure that there is no God? This is one reason why I feel that secular people, and those holding strongly to a secular lifestyle are themselves practicing a religion of ‘secularism.’ In other words, ‘secularism’ itself is a religion.

Key Point: Like it or not, we are all ‘exclusive’ in our own ways. Truth by nature is absolutely exclusive.

D) Fight the Right Battle

The worst thing for any soldier to be involved in is to fight the wrong war. Brilliant answers to the wrong question will only give us a failing grade. Right words spoken to the wrong person lead us nowhere. Our battle in the spiritual realm is not against flesh and blood. Paul warns:
For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms.” (Ephesians 6:12)

It is not exclusive claims that we should be concerned about. It is about truth claims. Truth by its very nature is ‘exclusive.’ If something is white, call it ‘white.’ If something is circular, call it ‘circular.’ Don’t simply play the game of political correctness, saying things that pleases man instead of God. Don’t be afraid to speak up on truth claims. We should not be embarrassed when we state what we believe. If those who accuse Christians of being ‘arrogant and exclusive’ in their truth claims about Jesus, let us not forget, that they too are ‘arrogant and exclusive’ in their own claims about their viewpoints about life. When we see a building on fire, and screams out to the occupants inside to get out, are we going to be embarrassed when they accuse us of being 'arrogant and exclusive' about calling 'fire?"

As I remember my belated uncle and his free thinking views, I feel that those who call themselves ‘free thinkers’ may not actually be free to think otherwise. Free-thinkers are more likely those who have chosen to limit themselves exclusively to seeing things their own way. No one else is allowed to change them. So, who now is exclusive?

THOUGHT: “Integrity is telling myself the truth. And honesty is telling the truth to other people.” (Spencer Johnson)


Copyright by SabbathWalk. This devotional is sent to you free of charge. If you feel blessed or ministered to by SabbathWalk weekly devotionals, feel free to forward to friends, or to invite them to subscribe online at . You can also send me an email at for comments or enquiries.

No comments:

Post a Comment